The Rising Tide of Online Returns
Retailers are bracing for a tidal wave of returns, particularly in the post-holiday rush. According to the National Retail Federation, online returns now account for 20.8% of total merchandise returns, costing U.S. retailers over $816 billion in 2022 alone. Returns surge as shoppers take advantage of flexible return policies, often buying multiple sizes or colors of a product with the intent of returning most of them—a trend known as “bracketing.”
Why Returns Are So Costly
Returns aren’t just about taking back an unwanted item—they involve an entire logistical operation. Here’s why they’re so expensive:
- Transportation Costs: Every return means the item travels back to the retailer or a processing center, doubling shipping emissions and costs.
- Inspection and Processing: Once returned, items need to be inspected, cleaned, and repackaged a labor-intensive process.
- Restocking or Disposal: Not all returned items can be resold. In fact, many items are discarded due to damage, hygiene concerns, or the cost of restocking exceeding the value of the item.
Some retailers are now turning to reverse logistics companies like Happy Returns to streamline the process. These companies consolidate returned items into fewer shipments, cutting costs and emissions. However, even with these innovations, the cost of handling returns remains steep.
The Environmental Impact
Beyond financial costs, returns have a significant environmental toll. The transportation involved in reverse logistics contributes heavily to carbon emissions. Meanwhile, returned items that cannot be resold often end up in landfills. For example, fast fashion returns, which are notoriously difficult to process, contribute to billions of pounds of waste annually.
What This Means for Shoppers
While many of us appreciate generous return policies, it’s important to consider the broader impact of our choices. Each return adds to a retailer's costs and contributes to environmental harm. Some companies are now introducing fees for returns to offset these costs, while others are implementing technology like virtual try-ons to reduce the need for returns in the first place.
A Call for Smarter Shopping
As consumers, we can help reduce the burden of returns by making more intentional purchasing decisions. Here are a few tips:
- Check Sizing Guides: Avoid bracketing by carefully reviewing size charts and reading reviews before purchasing.
- Consider the Cost: Think twice before ordering items you’re unsure about.
- Support Sustainable Brands: Choose retailers that prioritize eco-friendly practices for returns and packaging.
The cost of returns is more than just a line item on a retailer’s balance sheet—it’s a challenge that affects businesses, the environment, and ultimately, all of us. By shopping smarter and returning less, we can help alleviate these hidden costs and create a more sustainable retail ecosystem.
Resources